Episode 272: What Most SEO Pros Are Doing Wrong feat. Steve Toth
Most SEO shortcuts age badly, because Google changes and buyers also ask AI tools. Steve Toth and I talk about what was going wrong in May 2025, and why you still have to write for people, not just for the old ranking tricks. If the company still depends on you, start with the Founder’s Trap. If AI is already part of how buyers judge you, read how that first impression gets formed.
Steve publishes SEO Notebook and AI Notebook, and he also runs Notebook Agency. On this May 2025 episode he said SEO Notebook was at almost 20,000 subscribers, about six years in. This is not a current audit of anyone’s site, including ours. It is a May 2025 conversation about a profession that was still leaning on old habits while the way people search was already changing.
Backlinks came up because that used to be the whole conversation. Steve’s answer was not that they stopped mattering. He said they still matter, especially when you are comparing a new site with an established one. Between two established sites, he said the importance is less automatic. Building links as a shortcut, and skipping the work of being useful, is the mistake.
The same pattern showed up with AI-written content. Asking a tool to “write me an article” is not a strategy in a niche that needs subject-matter expertise. Steve’s point was that the content still needs a human touch. He also said he uses AI to strengthen writing, not to replace the expertise. That is closer to how we think about credibility and thought leadership than it is to a publishing factory.
If you want a concrete move from this episode, take one page you care about and make it more useful to a person before you spend another hour chasing a trick that will be stale next year.
KEY TAKEAWAYS:
- This is a May 2025 conversation. It is not a current site audit.
- Old ranking tricks age badly when both Google and buyers change how they search.
- Backlinks still matter, especially for a new site, and they are not a shortcut that replaces useful content.
- Raw AI output is weak in niches that need subject-matter expertise.
- A human touch is still the difference between content someone will trust and content they will skip.
- Write for people first. The rest of the system is downstream of that.
Connect with Steve Toth:
- SEO Notebook, AI Notebook, and Notebook Agency, as named on the episode.
Learn more about Predictable Profits and the Predictable Profits Community.
Growing a business is hard, but it doesn’t have to be. In this podcast, we discuss strategies for growing and expanding a business beyond seven figures.
The show mixes practical teaching with expert interviews so you can take ideas back to your company and use them. Enjoy the show.
Please rate, review, and subscribe so you don’t miss future episodes. Your reviews help us improve the show.
Follow Charles Gaudet and Predictable Profits on social media: Facebook: facebook.com/PredictableProfits Instagram: instagram.com/predictableprofits Twitter: twitter.com/charlesgaudet LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/charlesgaudet Visit: Predictable Profits Predictable Profits Community
FAQ
What are most SEO pros getting wrong, according to this episode?
Relying on old tricks while Google changes and buyers also ask AI tools. Charles and Steve Toth dated that critique to this May 2025 conversation. The work is still to write something a person actually wants to read.
Do backlinks still matter?
Steve said they still matter, especially when you are weighing a new site against an established one. Between two established sites, he said the importance is less automatic. Do not treat backlinks as a shortcut that replaces useful content.
How should AI-written content be used, if at all, in this conversation?
Steve’s qualification is that raw AI output is not enough in niches that need subject-matter expertise. The content needs a human touch. He also said he uses AI to strengthen writing, not to replace the expertise.
Did you catch our last episode?
So don’t forget to subscribe to the show to get that episode as soon as it is released. Until then, be profitable.
